Reports: White House altered official transcript of Joe Biden's 'garbage' remarks
Posted on 11/01/2024
WASHINGTON – White House press officials reportedly altered the official transcript of a call in which President Joe Biden appeared to disparage supporters of former President Donald Trump, according to published reports.
The change to the official transcript drew objections from the stenographers who are charged with documenting the president’s remarks for posterity, the Associated Press reported, citing two government officials and an internal email obtained by the news agency. Fox News said it also had confirmed the existence of the email.
The revelation comes as the White House is dealing with the uproar caused by Biden’s remarks, which sparked a backlash among outraged Republicans and created a political dilemma for Vice President Kamala Harris just days before the Nov. 5 election.
Biden made the remark during a Zoom call on Tuesday with Voto Latino, an organization encouraging Latino and Hispanic youth to become politically engaged. On the call, Biden denounced offensive jokes that podcast host Tony Hinchcliffe made about Puerto Rico during Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally over the weekend.
“Just the other day, a speaker at his rally called Puerto Rico a ‘floating island of garbage,’” Biden said. He added that the only “garbage” he saw “floating out there” were supporters, though it was unclear if he was referring just to Hinchcliffe or all of Trump’s fans.
More:Biden sparks Republican backlash after appearing to swipe at Trump's supporters
The White House released a transcript of Biden’s remarks Tuesday night that added an apostrophe to Biden’s quote, which made it read “supporter’s” instead of “supporters.” White House aides insisted the president was referring to Hinchcliffe, not all Americans who support the former president.
The change to the transcript was made after the press office “conferred with the president,” according to an internal email from the head of the stenographers’ office that was obtained by the AP. The news organization said it confirmed the authenticity of the email by two government officials who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal matters.
The supervisor, in the email, said the press office’s handling of the matter amounted to “a breach of protocol and spoliation of transcript integrity between the Stenography and Press Offices,” the AP said.
“If there is a difference in interpretation, the Press Office may choose to withhold the transcript but cannot edit it independently,” the supervisor wrote, adding, “Our Stenography Office transcript — released to our distro, which includes the National Archives – is now different than the version edited and released to the public by Press Office staff.”
More:Trump pounces on Biden's 'garbage' comment. But he's used the same word for opponents
The stenographers office is charged with providing accurate transcripts of the president’s public and private remarks. Those transcripts are distributed to the public and the National Archives for preservation.
The AP said the two-person stenography team on duty the evening of Biden’s call – a “typer” and “proofer” – said any edit to the transcript would have to be approved by their supervisor, the head of stenographers’ office.
The supervisor was not immediately available to review the audio, but the press office went ahead and published the altered transcript on the White House website and distributed it to press and on social media in an effort to tamp down the story, AP reported.
The supervisor, a career employee of the White House, raised the concerns about the press office action – but did not weigh in on the accuracy of the edit – in an email to White House communications director Ben LaBolt, press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre and other press and communications officials, the AP reported.
Biden posted a message on X on Tuesday night attempting to clarify his remarks.
“Earlier today I referred to the hateful rhetoric about Puerto Rico spewed by Trump's supporter at his Madison Square Garden rally as garbage – which is the only word I can think of to describe it,” he wrote. “His demonization of Latinos is unconscionable. That's all I meant to say. The comments at that rally don't reflect who we are as a nation.”
White House senior deputy press secretary Andrew Bates posted the edited version of the quote on X and wrote that Biden was referring “to the hateful rhetoric at the Madison Square Garden rally as ‘garbage.’”
Asked for comment, Bates provided a statement Thursday night to USA TODAY that did not address whether the transcript had been changed.
“The president confirmed in his tweet on Tuesday evening that he was addressing the hateful rhetoric from the comedian at Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally,” the statement said. “That was reflected in the transcript.”
More:Can military forces be used to quash an 'enemy within,' like Trump suggested? Here's what to know
Biden's comment was met with outrage by Republican lawmakers and Trump himself. Trump, speaking Tuesday at a rally in Allentown, Pennsylvania, described Biden’s remarks as “terrible” and compared them to Hillary Clinton's comments calling some of Trump's supporters "deplorables" in 2016.
In Wisconsin on Wednesday, Trump rode in the cab of a garbage truck to draw attention to Biden’s remarks.
Harris also took issue with Biden’s comments, telling reporters that while the president clarified his remarks, she does not agree with criticisms of voters based on whom they're supporting.
Meanwhile, House Republicans raised concerns the White House may have violated the Presidential Records Act by revising the transcript of Biden’s remarks.
House Republican Conference Chairwoman Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., and Rep. James Comer, R-Ky., who chairs the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability, sent a letter Wednesday to White House Counsel Edward Siskel demanding that all documents and internal communications related to Biden’s statement and the inaccurate transcript be retained and preserved. The lawmakers also called on the White House to issue a corrected transcript containing the accurate wording.
“White House staff cannot rewrite the words of the President of the United States to be more politically on message,” the letter said. “Though President Biden’s relevance continues to diminish, his words continue to matter, even as they become increasingly divisive and erratic.”
Contributing: Karissa Waddick
Michael Collins covers the White House. Follow him on X @mcollinsNEWS.
The change to the official transcript drew objections from the stenographers who are charged with documenting the president’s remarks for posterity, the Associated Press reported, citing two government officials and an internal email obtained by the news agency. Fox News said it also had confirmed the existence of the email.
The revelation comes as the White House is dealing with the uproar caused by Biden’s remarks, which sparked a backlash among outraged Republicans and created a political dilemma for Vice President Kamala Harris just days before the Nov. 5 election.
Biden made the remark during a Zoom call on Tuesday with Voto Latino, an organization encouraging Latino and Hispanic youth to become politically engaged. On the call, Biden denounced offensive jokes that podcast host Tony Hinchcliffe made about Puerto Rico during Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally over the weekend.
“Just the other day, a speaker at his rally called Puerto Rico a ‘floating island of garbage,’” Biden said. He added that the only “garbage” he saw “floating out there” were supporters, though it was unclear if he was referring just to Hinchcliffe or all of Trump’s fans.
More:Biden sparks Republican backlash after appearing to swipe at Trump's supporters
The White House released a transcript of Biden’s remarks Tuesday night that added an apostrophe to Biden’s quote, which made it read “supporter’s” instead of “supporters.” White House aides insisted the president was referring to Hinchcliffe, not all Americans who support the former president.
The change to the transcript was made after the press office “conferred with the president,” according to an internal email from the head of the stenographers’ office that was obtained by the AP. The news organization said it confirmed the authenticity of the email by two government officials who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal matters.
The supervisor, in the email, said the press office’s handling of the matter amounted to “a breach of protocol and spoliation of transcript integrity between the Stenography and Press Offices,” the AP said.
“If there is a difference in interpretation, the Press Office may choose to withhold the transcript but cannot edit it independently,” the supervisor wrote, adding, “Our Stenography Office transcript — released to our distro, which includes the National Archives – is now different than the version edited and released to the public by Press Office staff.”
More:Trump pounces on Biden's 'garbage' comment. But he's used the same word for opponents
The stenographers office is charged with providing accurate transcripts of the president’s public and private remarks. Those transcripts are distributed to the public and the National Archives for preservation.
The AP said the two-person stenography team on duty the evening of Biden’s call – a “typer” and “proofer” – said any edit to the transcript would have to be approved by their supervisor, the head of stenographers’ office.
The supervisor was not immediately available to review the audio, but the press office went ahead and published the altered transcript on the White House website and distributed it to press and on social media in an effort to tamp down the story, AP reported.
The supervisor, a career employee of the White House, raised the concerns about the press office action – but did not weigh in on the accuracy of the edit – in an email to White House communications director Ben LaBolt, press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre and other press and communications officials, the AP reported.
Biden posted a message on X on Tuesday night attempting to clarify his remarks.
“Earlier today I referred to the hateful rhetoric about Puerto Rico spewed by Trump's supporter at his Madison Square Garden rally as garbage – which is the only word I can think of to describe it,” he wrote. “His demonization of Latinos is unconscionable. That's all I meant to say. The comments at that rally don't reflect who we are as a nation.”
White House senior deputy press secretary Andrew Bates posted the edited version of the quote on X and wrote that Biden was referring “to the hateful rhetoric at the Madison Square Garden rally as ‘garbage.’”
Asked for comment, Bates provided a statement Thursday night to USA TODAY that did not address whether the transcript had been changed.
“The president confirmed in his tweet on Tuesday evening that he was addressing the hateful rhetoric from the comedian at Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally,” the statement said. “That was reflected in the transcript.”
More:Can military forces be used to quash an 'enemy within,' like Trump suggested? Here's what to know
Biden's comment was met with outrage by Republican lawmakers and Trump himself. Trump, speaking Tuesday at a rally in Allentown, Pennsylvania, described Biden’s remarks as “terrible” and compared them to Hillary Clinton's comments calling some of Trump's supporters "deplorables" in 2016.
In Wisconsin on Wednesday, Trump rode in the cab of a garbage truck to draw attention to Biden’s remarks.
Harris also took issue with Biden’s comments, telling reporters that while the president clarified his remarks, she does not agree with criticisms of voters based on whom they're supporting.
Meanwhile, House Republicans raised concerns the White House may have violated the Presidential Records Act by revising the transcript of Biden’s remarks.
House Republican Conference Chairwoman Elise Stefanik, R-N.Y., and Rep. James Comer, R-Ky., who chairs the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability, sent a letter Wednesday to White House Counsel Edward Siskel demanding that all documents and internal communications related to Biden’s statement and the inaccurate transcript be retained and preserved. The lawmakers also called on the White House to issue a corrected transcript containing the accurate wording.
“White House staff cannot rewrite the words of the President of the United States to be more politically on message,” the letter said. “Though President Biden’s relevance continues to diminish, his words continue to matter, even as they become increasingly divisive and erratic.”
Contributing: Karissa Waddick
Michael Collins covers the White House. Follow him on X @mcollinsNEWS.
Comments( 0 )
0 0 4
0 0 6
